By Michael Adams
Austin Sports Journal

A Highland Park parent has filed a lawsuit against the University Interscholastic League, contesting the decision that forced the school’s boys soccer team to forfeit its Class 5A Division II state championship. 
 
The lawsuit, filed in Travis County, claims UIL leaders improperly applied Texas’ “no pass, no play” law when they ruled a player was ineligible. The player had received a failing grade in pre-calculus, which Highland Park Independent School District does not treat as an honors course. But the petition argues that state law and State Board of Education rules identify pre-calculus as an honors class, which should exempt it from eligibility calculations, according to the lawsuit.

You can read the full lawsuit here.
 
Highland Park won the April 11 title match against Liberty Hill, but the victory was later vacated after UIL determined a player competed in that game and four district contests.

The UIL’s State Executive Committee unanimously upheld that decision in July, rejecting an appeal brought by the player’s mother, Cara Pierce. 
 
In her amended petition, Pierce alleges UIL officials exceeded their authority by allowing local district policy to override state rules. She also argues the ruling subjected her son to harassment, including online messages accusing him of cheating.

The suit asks the court to reinstate Highland Park as the state champion and to invalidate UIL’s “Side-by-Side” guidance that permits districts to set stricter standards than state law. 
 
UIL officials, including executive director Jamey Harrison and committee chair Mike Motheral, are named as defendants, along with the State Board of Education.

The UIL has declined to comment on the pending litigation.
 
The petition emphasizes that UIL’s decision not only cost the Scots their championship but also created an uneven playing field statewide.