By Michael Adams 
Austin Sports Journal 

The 2025 Austin Sports Journal All-South Central Texas football awards and all-area teams recognize the players and coaches who defined the season across South Central Texas area from our 87 high schools we follow all season.  

Below is the area’s best of the best for the 2025 Texas high school football season.  

Mr. Austin Football 

Lake Travis’ Carter Buck makes a tackle against Dripping Springs during a high school football game on Oct. 17, 2025 at Tiger Stadium in Dripping Springs, Texas. (Courtesy photo by Jay Plotkin/Austin 6A Sports Report)

Carter Buck, Lake Travis, senior defensive end 

Carter Buck capped a dominant senior season by earning the Austin Sports Journal’s Mr. Austin Football honor after establishing himself as one of the most disruptive defensive players in the state.  

The Lake Travis defensive end was named District 26-6A most valuable player and played a central role in guiding the Cavaliers to a district championship and a berth in the Class 6A Division I state semifinals, including a landmark road win over rival Westlake for the first time in a decade. 

Buck’s impact went far beyond the stat sheet, though the numbers were eye-popping: 85 tackles, 36 tackles for loss, 22 sacks, 13 quarterback hurries, three forced fumbles, an interception and a pass deflection.  

Buck will take his talents to Fort Worth in the fall and join TCU, where he could be an immediate difference-maker for the Horned Frogs defense.  

Past winners:  

2024: Miles Teodecki, Vandegrift, junior quarterback 

2023: Cody Stoever, Wimberley, junior quarterback 

Offensive Player of the Year 

Anderson’s Caleb Crenshaw(1) makes a run during a football game against Hendrickson in the 2025 season. (Michael Adams/Austin Sports Journal)

Caleb Crenshaw, Anderson, senior running back 

Anderson running back Caleb Crenshaw is our All-South Central Texas Offensive Player of the Year after authoring one of the most impactful seasons in Trojan football history.  

The senior running back led the Trojans to a 10–2 record, the District 12-5A Division I championship – the program’s first district title since 2003 – and a second-round playoff appearance, while also being named the district’s offensive player of the year. 

Crenshaw rushed for 2,207 yards on 253 carries (8.7 yards per carry) and scored 24 touchdowns, combining power, vision and explosiveness to anchor Anderson’s offense all season. He will continue his career at Stephen F. Austin. 

Past winners:  

2024: Cody Stoever, Wimberley, junior quarterback 

2023: Ben Carter and Noah Long, Liberty Hill, senior running backs 

Defensive Player of the Year 

Smithson Valley’s Colton Hornsby (17) sacks Trey Wright (3) of Frisco Lone Star during the UIL Class 5A Division I state championship game on Friday, Dec. 19, 2025 at AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas. (Michael Adams/Austin Sports Journal)

Colton Hornsby, Smithson Valley, senior linebacker 

Smithson Valley linebacker Colton Hornsby is our All-South Central Texas Defensive Player of the Year after anchoring one of the most dominant defenses in Texas high school football. 

 The senior linebacker was named District 13-5A Division I Defensive Player of the Year and played a pivotal role in leading the Rangers to their second straight Class 5A Division I state championship, capping the postseason by being named the championship game’s defensive most valuable player. 

Hornsby was a relentless force at the heart of the defense, finishing the season with 137 tackles, eight sacks, 15 tackles for loss, an interception, a fumble recovery and a touchdown. He is uncommitted.  

Past winners:  

2024: Elliott Schaper, Westlake, senior defensive end 

2023: Luca Picucci, Dripping Springs, senior linebacker 

Newcomer of the Year 

Dripping Springs quarterback Chase Ames makes a pass during a football game against Vandegrift on Saturday, Dec. 6, 2025 at the Alamodome in San Antonio, Texas. (Courtesy photo by Wayland Clark)

Chase Ames, Dripping Springs, junior quarterback 

Chase Ames made an immediate impact in his first season as Dripping Springs’ starting quarterback and is our All-South Central Texas Newcomer of the Year. He helped guide the Tigers to the Class 6A Division II quarterfinals. The junior established himself as one of the most productive passers in the area and was named District 26-6A newcomer of the year.  

Ames threw for 3,682 yards and 47 touchdowns while limiting mistakes, finishing the season with just nine interceptions on 346 pass attempts.  

Past winners:  

2024: Jaxon Schad, Weiss, freshman quarterback 

2023: Rees Wise, Westlake, sophomore quarterback; Jorian Guinn Jr., Weiss, sophomore defensive back 

Small School Player of the Year 

The Llano Yellojackets run onto the field before a high school football game against the Jarrell Cougars on Friday, Sept. 19, 2025 at Cougar Stadium in Jarrell, Texas. (Paul Knight for the Austin Sports Journal)

Luke Davis, Llano, junior quarterback 

Luke Davis emerged as one of the most dynamic underclassmen in the region after leading Llano to a 13–2 record, a district championship and a berth in the Class 3A Division I state semifinals.  

The junior was the engine behind Llano’s deep postseason run, consistently delivering for the Yellowjackets while guiding one of the most balanced offenses in South Central Texas. 

Davis accounted for nearly 3,000 yards of total offense, throwing 2,501 yards and 33 touchdowns on 234 pass attempts while adding a dangerous element with his legs. He rushed for 458 yards on 92 carries and scored seven more touchdowns, showcasing his versatility, toughness and playmaking ability.  

Past winners:  

2024: Trey Mote, Llano, senior running back 

2023: No award 

Coach of the Year 

Smithson Valley head coach Larry Hill walks the sidelines before the UIL Class 5A Division I state championship game on Friday, Dec. 19, 2025 at AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas. (Michael Adams/Austin Sports Journal)

Larry Hill, Smithson Valley 

There’s no better choice for our 2025 All-South Central Texas Coach of the Year than Smithson Valley’s Larry Hill. The Rangers’ longtime head coach guided Smithson Valley to a second straight Class 5A Division I state championship, cementing one of the most impressive runs in program history. His latest title further solidifies his legacy as one of the top high school football coaches in Texas. 

Past winners:  

2024: Drew Sanders, Vandegrift 

2023: Scott Hermes, McNeil